As the great-grandson of Sir Leon Simon, let me assure you that I believe that the world would be a far better place if the Balfour declaration which he helped draft (“A scrap of paper that changed history”, 26 May) had never been drafted.
The fact that anti semites such as Balfour (and, later, antisemite evangelicals in the Bush administration) threw their weight behind the creation of Israel just goes to show that it was never in the interests of the Jewish people.
On the contrary, it was in the interests of Western imperialism to have a colonial settler state in Palestine, one that is wholly reliant on Western aid (military and economic) and that is wholly scared of the people who surround it (who were forcibly evicted from their homes in 1948). And it was in the interests of Western rulers to divert Jewish struggles away from anti-racism and social justice and towards the ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian peoples.
More and more Jews are coming to see what my great grandfather failed to see, that the only just solution in the Middle East is a Palestine in which Jews and Muslims, Arabs and Europeans, live alongside each other with equal rights and an equal stake in the state; a solution in which the Balfour Declaration is finally put to rest.
DAN MAYER LONDON N10
(The Independent 3 June 2005)
- Evangelicals, the Balfour Declaration and Zionism
- Prophet of Doom: E.T. Richmond, Palestine 1920-1924
- The Balfour Declaration, 2 November 1917: A Fateful Improbability
- Renewed call for justice and reconciliation in the Holy Land on the centenary of the Balfour Declaration
- An interview between Mr Balfour and Justice Brandeis, Paris 1919
- Memories Of The Future: On The Anniversary Of The Balfour Declaration
- Balfour Centenary Declaration
- Report of Britain’s Broken Promise: Time for a New Approach
- Prominent Israelis call for recognition of Palestine
- A calamitous promise
- Calls for Acknowledgement of Britain’s Role
- The Balfour Declaration: 100 Years On.
- Different ways of seeing the Balfour Declaration – BBC Radio 4 “Sunday” 1st October 2017
- You cannot ignore the sacred trust of civilisation or disdain the scholarship of Avi Shlaim: a review of Lord Leslie Turnberg’s Beyond the Balfour Declaration
- Palestine 1917-2017: Reflections on a refugee’s story, my great-grandfather’s war diary and the legacy of Britain’s actions in Palestine.
- The 1929 Palestine Riots: A Conflicted Jewish Historiography,
- Part II The 1929 Palestine Riots: A Conflicted Jewish Historiography
- Unfinished business? Seeking peace through the door of justice in the Holy Land
- Mahatma Gandhi and the Wounds of History: Palestine, India and the British Empire in the 20th century
- Peel Commission
- Woodhead Commission
- The reversal of the Passfield White Paper, 1930-31 : a reassessment.
- The Balfour Declaration
- Palestine and Britain 1917-1948: Competing Policies, Creative Commemoration
- Balfour Declaration Centenary, 2017: towards constructive commemoration
Find out more
- 19th Century
- Anglo-French Declaration
- Balfour Declaration
- British Mandate
- Christian Zionism
- First World War
- Hussein Ibn Ali
- League of Nations
- Lloyd George
- London Jews Society
- Lord Curzon
- McMahon Hussain
- Middle East
- Palestine Mandate
- Sacred Trust
- Sherif Hussein
- Sykes Picot